Review “Case 3.1: A Strained Research Team” located in Chapter 3 of the textbook Leadership: Theory and Practice., Post a 250-300 word response to the questions located at the end of the case. In your response be sure to address the strengths and weaknesses of the three-skill approach in this situation.

Three-Skill Approach
Three-Skill Approach

The case of the strained research team highlights the challenges faced by a research team due to the poor leadership skills of its leader. The leader’s lack of emotional intelligence, technical skills, and conceptual skills has resulted in strained team relationships, poor communication, and an overall decline in productivity. The three-skill approach, which includes technical, human, and conceptual skills, can help leaders navigate complex situations and lead their teams effectively.

In this situation, the leader lacks all three skills. The technical skill refers to the knowledge and expertise required to carry out a specific job. The leader’s technical skills were lacking, which led to a lack of confidence and respect from the team members. The human skill refers to the ability to work well with others, understand their needs and motivations, and build relationships. The leader failed to understand and address the interpersonal dynamics within the team, which resulted in conflict and resentment. Finally, the conceptual skill refers to the ability to think critically, identify problems, and develop solutions. The leader failed to identify the root causes of the team’s problems and failed to develop a clear plan of action to address them.

Despite the shortcomings of the three-skill approach, it does offer some strengths. The approach highlights the importance of a well-rounded leader who can effectively manage the technical, interpersonal, and strategic aspects of the job. It encourages leaders to identify their strengths and weaknesses and develop skills in areas where they are lacking. However, the three-skill approach does not account for the ever-changing and unpredictable nature of organizational contexts. The approach assumes that the leader’s skills will always be sufficient to address the challenges faced by the organization.

In conclusion, the three-skill approach is a useful framework to help leaders navigate complex situations, but it does have limitations. In the case of the strained research team, the leader’s lack of technical, human, and conceptual skills created a challenging situation that required more than just a well-rounded leader. The leader’s lack of emotional intelligence, in particular, contributed significantly to the team’s problems. Therefore, leaders need to continually develop their skills and adapt to the ever-changing and unpredictable nature of organizational contexts to be effective.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *